Signs your garage door spring is broken
If you heard a loud bang from the garage and now the door won’t open, a spring has almost certainly broken. Springs counterbalance the door’s weight, often 130 to 400+ pounds, so when one snaps, the opener can’t lift the door on its own.
- A visible gap in the coiled spring on the bar above the door
- The door rises a few inches, then stops or reverses
- The door feels extremely heavy when lifted by hand
- Loose or hanging lift cables
- The opener hums, strains or clicks but the door doesn’t move
What to do now: leave the door closed, don’t keep pressing the opener (it can strip the gears), and don’t try to adjust the spring yourself. Call (239) 880-8770. If your car is trapped, tell us and we’ll prioritize it.
Torsion vs. extension springs
Torsion springs sit on a steel bar above the door and twist to lift it. They’re on most Naples homes built in the last 25 years, last longer, and run more smoothly. Extension springs stretch along the horizontal tracks on each side; they’re common on older single-car doors and must have safety cables running through them so a broken spring can’t whip loose.
Converting an older extension-spring door to a torsion system is often worth it when you’re replacing springs anyway. Ask and we’ll quote both. For reference, Angi’s 2026 data puts a national extension-to-torsion conversion at $400 to $800 (Angi).
| Torsion springs | Extension springs | |
|---|---|---|
| Where | On a bar above the door | Along the horizontal tracks on each side |
| How they work | Twist (wind) to store energy | Stretch to store energy |
| Common on | Most newer Naples homes, double doors | Older and lighter single-car doors |
| Ride quality | Smoother, better balance | Can jerk as springs stretch |
| Safety | Contained on the bar | Must have safety cables through each spring |
| Our price | $200 to $350 single, $275 to $550 pair | $180 to $320 pair with safety cables |
What spring replacement costs in Naples
Most spring jobs fall between $200 and $550 installed. The price depends on spring size (set by your door’s weight and height), whether there are one or two springs, and whether cables or rollers also need replacing.
| Job | Typical price |
|---|---|
| Torsion springs (pair) | $275 to $550 |
| Extension springs (pair) with safety cables | $180 to $320 |
| Lift cables replaced | $150 to $350 |
| Opener repair | $100 to $350 |
| New belt-drive opener, installed | $450 to $900 |
| New double-car door, wind-rated | $2,800 to $8,000 |
Naples-area ranges, updated November 2026. Your exact price is quoted on site before work begins.
How we replace springs
- Weigh and measure. We size springs to your actual door weight, not just copy the old ones, which may have been wrong.
- Replace in pairs on two-spring doors, with oil-tempered or galvanized springs suited to coastal air.
- Inspect cables, drums, bearings and rollers: a broken spring often frays cables.
- Balance and test. The door should stay put when lifted halfway by hand. We test the opener’s force settings and auto-reverse.
Why springs fail early near the Gulf
Every spring is rated for a set number of cycles, typically about 10,000 for standard springs, or roughly 7 years at four cycles a day. High-cycle springs are rated for 25,000 or more. In Naples, salt air and humidity add corrosion: rust pits the steel and creates weak points where springs snap. The door industry’s own guidance (DASMA) notes that rust reduces a spring’s wire and corrosion pits speed up fatigue cracks. Coastal homes benefit from galvanized, coated or high-cycle springs and a lubrication visit every six months. See our salt-air maintenance service.
Standard vs. high-cycle springs
A spring’s life is measured in cycles (one open plus one close), and high-cycle springs simply last more of them. Ratings vary by manufacturer, but standard residential springs are commonly rated around 10,000 cycles and high-cycle springs at 25,000 or more. DASMA’s technical data sheet on spring life explains how wire size and corrosion affect that number (DASMA TDS-190).
| Spring | Typical rating | At 4 cycles a day | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard | About 10,000 cycles | Roughly 7 years | Light use, budget repairs |
| High-cycle | 25,000 cycles or more | Roughly 17 years or more | Busy garages, the main entry to the house |
The years column is simple arithmetic, not a guarantee: salt air, humidity and an unbalanced door all shorten real-world life. If your family uses the garage as the front door, high-cycle springs usually cost less per year.
Why DIY spring replacement is dangerous
Torsion springs store enough energy to lift a door weighing hundreds of pounds, and releasing that energy by accident can cause serious injury. Winding a spring takes proper winding bars, the right number of turns for your door, and knowledge of which parts are under tension, including the bottom brackets and cables. Online videos make it look simple, but a slipped bar or the wrong spring size is how most garage door injuries happen. Spring replacement is one job to leave to a trained technician.
How Naples prices compare
Our installed prices are $200 to $350 for a single torsion spring and $275 to $550 for a pair, including balancing and a safety check. Nationally, Angi’s 2026 data puts spring replacement at an average of $250, with most jobs between $150 and $350 (Angi). Pairs, heavy doors, high-cycle or coated springs and extra parts like cables move a job toward the top of the range. See all prices in the repair cost guide.
Spring repair across Naples
We replace springs throughout Naples, Marco Island, Bonita Springs and Estero. Waterfront homes in Old Naples, Port Royal and on Marco Island see the most rust-related failures; Pelican Bay and North Naples homes often still have their original builder-grade springs. Seasonal residents can book a pre-season check so a tired spring is replaced before it snaps. See all service areas. If a spring has broken and your car is stuck inside, call for emergency service.
Related repairs
A door that came down hard after a spring broke may also need cable, roller or track repair. If the opener strained against a broken spring, we’ll check it too. See opener repair.
